• Home
  • Cake Flavors and Fillings
  • Macaron Flavors
  • Party Planning
  • More
    • Home
    • Cake Flavors and Fillings
    • Macaron Flavors
    • Party Planning
  • Home
  • Cake Flavors and Fillings
  • Macaron Flavors
  • Party Planning

The Difference Between Signature and Custom Cakes

"A party without cake is just a meeting" -Julia Child

We get calls daily from wonderful people who'd like to order a cake. We realize that all the options can be overwhelming and wanted to offer cakes that are both customer and staff favorites. We created our Signature Line of 8 incredible cakes. These cakes have dynamic flavor combinations and are decorated like the picture, every time. It takes out the guesswork, and you know exactly what you're getting. Our Signature Cakes are offered as 6 or 8 inches round. Signature cakes are priced at $60 for a six inch and $80 for an eight inch.


Of course, if you have a particular flavor or design in mind, scroll down to our Custom Cake section and we will work with you to create the cake of your dreams. Your flavor selection, icing & filling choice, and decorated to suit your event. Custom cakes are each a work of art and can also include fondant accents, and edible prints. Custom cakes can be up to three tiers, each with its own unique flavor. Due to the uniqueness of each cake, the cost is based on your selections. Please scroll down for more information on ordering custom cakes.


Whether it's a Sgnature Cake, or a Custom Cake, it's sure to please!

Our Signature Cakes

Salted Caramel

Three layers of moist caramel cake with salted caramel buttercream, topped with a caramel drip, and even more caramel on top! Then, dusted with a little sprinkle of sea salt.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Chocolate chip cake layered with cookie dough buttercream, topped with more chocolate chips and edible cookie dough scoops!

Lemon Overload

Just the right amount of lemon in this three layer cake sandwiched between our house made lemon curd and finished in a silky lemon buttercream.

Italian Rainbow Cookie

Three colors of layered almond cake with raspberry preserves in between and covered in chocolate ganache.

Strawberry Banana

Banana layer cake filled with fresh strawberries and strawberry preserves decorated in a classic, vintage style with strawberry buttercream.

Orange Cardamom

Orange zest, cardamom, and cinnamon cake layered with a whipped honey buttercream. This cake is a perfect balance of flavors!

Pistachio Raspberry

Pistachio Raspberry

Freshly ground pistachios baked into our spongey cake layered with raspberry preserves and covered in raspberry buttercream rosettes.

Café Mocha

Pistachio Raspberry

Freshly brewed coffee is baked into our chocolate cake which is sandwiched between cold brew buttercream below a chocolate ganache drip.

How to Order a Custom Cake

First: Select Your Size

all round cakes are three layers, quarter and half sheet cakes are two layers. all servings are based on "catering cuts" not triangular slices; think of the slice you would be served at a wedding.

Six inch

59

serves 12-15 people

Eight inch

79

serves approximately 25 people

Ten inch

99

serves approximately 40 people

Twelve inch

119

serves approximately 60 people

Quarter Sheet

79

serves approximately 25 people

Half Sheet

119

serves approximately 50 people


Second: Select Your Cake Flavor

from traditional to funky, we've got something for everyone! and if you don't see your favorite listed, just ask. gluten free is also available on virtually anything we make.

Included Flavors

no additional cost

vanilla, chocolate, chocolate chip, funfetti, lemon, marble, almond

Custom Flavors

varies

red velvet, carrot, café mocha, pumpkin, cranberry orange, gingerbread, peppermint mocha, strawberry shortcake, blueberry pancake, cinnamon roll, pistachio, lemon berry, chocolate peanut butter, Italian rainbow cookie, snickerdoodle, caramel apple, bananas foster, salted caramel, pistachio raspberry, chocolate strawberry, raspberry almond, orange creamsicle, cherry cola, cotton candy, orange cardamom and more


Third: Fillings and Frostings

buttercream is the standard, but based on your cake flavor, other options are available. If you're unsure, we'd be happy to discuss what works best and ideal flavor combinations.

Buttercream

no additional cost

buttercream is our specialty; vanilla and chocolate are the most popular selections

Custom Flavors

varies

cream cheese (a fan favorite!) whipped cream (available on shortcakes only) fresh fruit filings, fruit preserves and flavored buttercreams are available by request. Please contact us for a quote.


Tiered Cakes

People often confuse tiers with layers. While our standard cakes have two or three layers, they are one tier. That means, one size, all the same layers. For more servings and an elegant design, we offer two and sometimes three tiered cakes. There are far too many variables including servings needed, flavor(s) of cake selected and decor options for us to include a price. We price each cake individually after discussing the specific details. Please contact us to design your unique creation.

We're adding new flavors everyday, please don't hesitate to ask if you don't see your favorite.

Copyright © 2026 Amici Mullica Hill LLC - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by